02-15-2009, 02:02 PM
Seems to me, Tailgrabber, that you're asking two different questions.
First, the most common rod size, and then, a good smallmouth size.
As to the most common, it used to be #6, because that's what all the writers touted as a general purpose rod. Of late, however, it's more likely a #5. Personally, I still recommend the #6 for a one-rod angler. My size recommendation is something in the 8 foot range.
As to smallies, a lot depends on the fishing conditions and average size of the fish. An 8 weight is great if you're fishing large lakes and impoundments, where the fish run larger and conditions can be tough. For most stream fishing, on the other hand, you are overgunned with a #8.
For stream smallies, choose the same rod you would for trout in those waters. Which usually mans a #6 or lighter.
One thing to keep in mind, when choosing a rod, is the kind of flies you'll be casting. I suspect the guys using 8 weights for smallmouth are doing so because they're throwing a lot of hair bugs and similar air-resistent flies, and need the rod strength to carry them.
It's the same reason we use #10 weights for musky. Don't need them to subdue a water wolf. But do need them to toss those big, air resistent flies.
Brook
http://www.the-outdoor-sports-advisor.com
[signature]
First, the most common rod size, and then, a good smallmouth size.
As to the most common, it used to be #6, because that's what all the writers touted as a general purpose rod. Of late, however, it's more likely a #5. Personally, I still recommend the #6 for a one-rod angler. My size recommendation is something in the 8 foot range.
As to smallies, a lot depends on the fishing conditions and average size of the fish. An 8 weight is great if you're fishing large lakes and impoundments, where the fish run larger and conditions can be tough. For most stream fishing, on the other hand, you are overgunned with a #8.
For stream smallies, choose the same rod you would for trout in those waters. Which usually mans a #6 or lighter.
One thing to keep in mind, when choosing a rod, is the kind of flies you'll be casting. I suspect the guys using 8 weights for smallmouth are doing so because they're throwing a lot of hair bugs and similar air-resistent flies, and need the rod strength to carry them.
It's the same reason we use #10 weights for musky. Don't need them to subdue a water wolf. But do need them to toss those big, air resistent flies.
Brook
http://www.the-outdoor-sports-advisor.com
[signature]