04-23-2013, 03:10 PM
[quote FishingLunatic]
I still don't think anyone would be able to get me to try eating a carp but I'd be more happy with people actually eating them than what we're doing. I think really the spot I care about carp the most is the jordan river. It's my spot of go and try to try to catch as big of a fish as I can. I don't think we need to do anything to the actual Jordan river and really hope we don't do something like poison the whole river and end up killing all the carp and other fish. To me, I dont see why why can't we shouldn't be able to have them there because it no longer has native trout and such that used to live in it. Plus I've seen multiple areas of the Jordan river and they have Dams and there's no way they'd be able to end up back in Utah Lake.[/quote]
Why should we get rid of the carp in the Jordan River? BECASUE IT WILL BECOME A WAY BETTER FISHERY..........THATS WHY!
There are a few trout in the Jordan and there would be a hell of a lot more of them if the nasty carp didn't compete and eat all the dam food in the river. Imagine the fishery we'd have without those stupid things.
But I know you will never be convinced because you are the 20 something year old taking classes at the U of U and that makes you better than anyone else on here, even those with degrees to their name.
So you admit you would not eat a carp but everyone else should if they don't release it? LOL! I would totally expect that rational by you and no one else on here.
[signature]
I still don't think anyone would be able to get me to try eating a carp but I'd be more happy with people actually eating them than what we're doing. I think really the spot I care about carp the most is the jordan river. It's my spot of go and try to try to catch as big of a fish as I can. I don't think we need to do anything to the actual Jordan river and really hope we don't do something like poison the whole river and end up killing all the carp and other fish. To me, I dont see why why can't we shouldn't be able to have them there because it no longer has native trout and such that used to live in it. Plus I've seen multiple areas of the Jordan river and they have Dams and there's no way they'd be able to end up back in Utah Lake.[/quote]
Why should we get rid of the carp in the Jordan River? BECASUE IT WILL BECOME A WAY BETTER FISHERY..........THATS WHY!
There are a few trout in the Jordan and there would be a hell of a lot more of them if the nasty carp didn't compete and eat all the dam food in the river. Imagine the fishery we'd have without those stupid things.
But I know you will never be convinced because you are the 20 something year old taking classes at the U of U and that makes you better than anyone else on here, even those with degrees to their name.
So you admit you would not eat a carp but everyone else should if they don't release it? LOL! I would totally expect that rational by you and no one else on here.
[signature]