I use the Okuma's for my spinning tackle in salt and freshwater and they work very well. They are strong and smooth. There really are a lot of great quality reels out there, it's hard to say who's product is better quality. Personally, if you wanted strength, i'd go with the Penn Spinning tackle.
Penn makes specific model spinning tackle out of steel. They are hard core tough and unmatched by reels of equal cost. Only the Van Staals are truely superior.
If you wanted smooth, i'd go with your Japanese reels like Shimano
If you wanted in between, i'd go with Okuma or Abu Garcia.
This is the type of Okuma I have with the live bait feature. It's put the breaks on everything from 50 pound flathead catfish to 120 pound reef sharks. These reels don't play. Don't believe me? Check out my photo gallery. I catch big fish.
Quantum also makes a good spinning reel. I have a Quantum ultra light spooled with 10 pound super braid on an ultra light ugly stix. It's a 10 year old reel and still works flawlessly. I've caught everything from hand sized bream and 10 pound mudfish to 2 and 3 pound black sea bass on the reef. [cool]
Honestly, I think what really matters is knowing how to use the reel properly and doing regular maintenance. If you don't clean and lubricate the reel, it's not going to last. No different than buying a new car. If you don't keep the oil changed, it's just a matter of time before it blows up. If you don't keep your reels cleaned and lubricated with fresh oil, it's just a matter of time before they blow up.
It's simple. Keep your line changed out. Don't put line on your reel that is stronger than the limits of your drag system or your angling ability. Keep it clean and lubed. If you do that, even a cheap reel will last a long, long time.
[signature]